How It WorksProductsExamplesBlog
LoginSign upGo to Dashboard

Gift ideas

What I Love About You Book: How to Make One, With 60 Prompts to Fill It

A What I Love About You book is one of the simplest gifts there is, and one of the easiest to get wrong. Five ways to make one, sixty prompts for the pages that stall, and how to turn a list of reasons into a story.

Last reviewed . Written by our editorial team from general gifting knowledge and from how myComics works. The formats, prompts and advice are our own opinion; we did not survey couples. One of the five formats is a comic version of the book, which is what we make at myComics, so read that part knowing where we stand.

By the myComics.ai Editorial Team9 min read

For couples · Christmas and Valentine’s · Editorial disclosure

a couple in their early thirties at a small kitchen table on a winter evening, a woman with a short black bob and freckles in a mustard yellow jumper and a man with curly brown hair and round glasses in a dark green flannel shirt, the man smiling with his hand over his mouth as he reads an open cartoon style comic book titled Things I Love About You, the open pages showing the two of them drawn as comic characters dancing badly in a tiny kitchen and sharing a plate of burnt pancakes, two mugs and a candle on the table

Quick answer

  • A What I Love About You book is a short book of specific reasons you love someone. It works for Christmas, Valentine’s Day, anniversaries and birthdays because the content is the relationship, not the object.
  • There are five ways to make one: a fill-in journal, a handmade notebook, a reasons jar, a printed photo book of reasons, or a comic where the reasons become scenes.
  • The best reasons are specific and a little funny. Write about moments and habits, not adjectives. “The way you narrate the dog’s thoughts” beats “you are funny”.
  • Most books stall around reason twenty. Use the sixty prompts below, write over a week rather than one night, and stop at a number that feels honest.

A What I Love About You book is exactly what it sounds like: a small book where every page says one thing you love about someone. It is one of the simplest gifts there is, and one of the most kept. People hold on to these books for decades, long after the jumper and the perfume are gone. It is also easy to get wrong. Most of them start strong, run out of ideas around page twenty, and end with “you are kind” written three different ways. This guide covers five ways to make a What I Love About You book, sixty prompts for the pages that stall, and how to write reasons that sound like the two of you rather than like a greeting card.

What is a What I Love About You book?

It is a short book of reasons, written by you, about one person. The classic version is a fill-in journal with a printed prompt on each page (“I love the way you…”) and a blank space for your answer. But the idea works in any format: a notebook, a jar, a photo book, even a comic.

What makes it work is that the content cannot be bought. Anyone can order flowers. Only you know that your partner hums the same three notes when they cook, or that they still keep the receipt from your first dinner. A good reasons book is a collection of those details.

It suits almost any occasion where you want to say something sincere: Christmas, Valentine’s Day, an anniversary, a birthday, a long distance reunion, or simply a hard year that deserves a thank you.

Which format should you choose?

There are five main ways to make one, and each suits a different amount of time and a different kind of person.

  1. A fill-in journal. Bookshops and online stores sell ready made journals with a prompt on every page. It is the fastest option: you buy it, fill it in over a week and wrap it. The prompts help, but they are the same for everyone, so your answers have to do all the personal work.
  2. A handmade notebook. A plain notebook, your handwriting, photos glued in, ticket stubs, a pressed flower from the wedding. It takes longer and looks less polished, which is exactly the charm. Your handwriting is part of the gift.
  3. A reasons jar. Fold each reason into a small note and fill a jar, one to open every day. It spreads the gift over weeks or a whole year, which is lovely for long distance couples.
  4. A printed photo book of reasons. One photo per page, one reason under each. It looks finished and lasts, and it works well when your reasons are tied to places and trips. Order it early, because printing takes time.
  5. A comic where each reason becomes a scene. Instead of writing “I love how you dance in the kitchen”, you show it: the two of you drawn as comic characters, dancing badly next to a pan of burnt pancakes. More on how this works below.

If you are short on time, choose the journal or the jar. If your partner is sentimental about objects, go handmade. If your reasons are really memories, a photo book or a comic will carry them better than a list.

close view of a woman in her early thirties with a short black bob and freckles in a mustard yellow jumper sitting on a sofa under a blanket, holding an open cartoon style comic book titled Things I Love About You, the pages showing her and a man with curly brown hair and round glasses drawn as comic characters waiting at a rainy bus stop under one coat and then laughing at a small kitchen table, warm lamp light and fairy lights blurred behind her

How do you make a What I Love About You book as a comic?

A comic version turns your list into short scenes. Each reason gets a page or a panel: the first time you saw them, the habit that drives you mad and that you secretly love, the night they drove two hours to bring you soup. It is funnier than a written list, because you can exaggerate (the soup delivery becomes a rescue mission through a snowstorm), and it still says the same thing.

On myComics.ai you upload photos of each of you (three to eight clear photos per person work best), describe the moments behind your reasons in plain words, and choose a style, such as cartoon, manga, superhero or vintage. The first pages are ready in minutes. Then you make it yours: rewrite every speech bubble so it sounds like you, regenerate any page with an instruction, and put the most important reason on the last page. A full book is a cover, twenty story pages and a back cover, so it fits a handful of reasons told properly rather than a hundred short lines. You can read it online, download it as a PDF, or order it printed.

Two honest limits. The drawing is a stylized likeness, closer to a caricature than a portrait. And it works best when your reasons come with stories attached. If what you want to say is a long list of small things, a journal or a jar holds that better. Our guide to the personalized love comic book goes deeper into choosing the moments, and if you are weighing an avatar reasons book against a comic, our comparison of LoveBook and a personalized comic covers the differences.

How do you write reasons that do not sound generic?

Most reasons books fail the same way: they use adjectives instead of moments. “You are funny” is true and forgettable. “The way you narrate the dog’s thoughts in a posh accent” is the line they will read out to friends. Four rules help.

  • Write moments, not qualities. Replace every adjective with the moment that proves it.
  • Use their words. Quote things they actually said. Nobody forgets seeing their own joke in print.
  • Include one flaw you love. The snoring, the terrible parking, the forty minute goodbyes. It makes the rest believable.
  • Write over a week. Keep a note on your phone and add a reason whenever one happens. By Sunday you will have more than you can use.

What should you write? 60 prompts for a What I Love About You book

Use these when the page goes blank. Answer them with a moment, not a word.

The beginning

  1. The first thing I noticed about you was…
  2. I knew I liked you when…
  3. On our first date, I loved that you…
  4. The message from you I reread the most is…
  5. The moment I realized this was serious was…
  6. I still smile when I think about the day we…

Everyday habits 7. I love the way you make coffee, tea or breakfast… 8. I love what you do when you think nobody is watching… 9. I love the face you make when… 10. I love the song you always sing when… 11. I love how you talk to animals, babies or plants… 12. I love the way you say my name when… 13. I love your Sunday mornings because… 14. I love the way you get ready to go out… 15. I love the snack you always steal from my plate… 16. I love how you fall asleep…

When things are hard 17. I love how you looked after me when… 18. I love that you never once… 19. I love that you stayed calm when… 20. I love what you said to me the day… 21. I love that you always know when I need… 22. I love how you made the move, the new job or the bad year easier by…

What makes you laugh 23. The funniest thing you ever did was… 24. I love your terrible jokes, especially… 25. I love it when you do the voice of… 26. Our best disaster was… 27. I love that you still laugh at… 28. The most you in a sentence is when you said…

Who you are 29. I admire how you… 30. I love how you treat people who… 31. I love what you are like with your friends when… 32. I love how stubborn you are about… 33. I love that you care so much about… 34. I love the way you get excited about… 35. I am proud of you for… 36. I love the flaw that I would never change, which is…

Us 37. My favourite trip with you was… because… 38. My favourite photo of us is… because… 39. Our best tradition is… 40. I love our private joke about… 41. My favourite ordinary day with you was… 42. I love that we both… 43. I love that we are completely different about… 44. The place that feels like us is… 45. I love the song that is ours because… 46. I love that you taught me…

Small things 47. I love your handwriting on… 48. I love the smell of… 49. I love your hands when… 50. I love the jumper, the hat or the jacket you always wear… 51. I love how you organize… 52. I love the way you leave notes… 53. I love how you choose presents… 54. I love your laugh when…

What comes next 55. Next year I want us to… 56. One day I want to take you to… 57. When we are old I hope we still… 58. A promise I want to make you is… 59. The thing I want to thank you for most is… 60. If I could only say one thing, it would be…

side view of a man in his early thirties with curly brown hair and round glasses in a dark green flannel shirt holding up a closed slim comic book titled Things I Love About You to show a woman with a short black bob and freckles in a mustard yellow jumper, the cover showing the two of them drawn as cartoon characters sharing one coat in the rain, the woman leaning against his shoulder and laughing, a window with snow and a small decorated tree behind them

How many reasons should you include, and how do you structure the book?

Fewer than you think. Twenty strong reasons are better than a hundred padded ones. Many people choose a number with meaning, such as one reason for every month or every year together, or the day of your anniversary. If you get to a number and the reasons start repeating, stop there.

A simple structure keeps the book readable:

Part What goes in it How many pages
Opening How it started: the first thing you noticed, the first date Two to four
Middle Habits, hard moments, what makes you laugh Most of the book
Turning point The one reason that matters most One
Closing What comes next, and a promise One or two

Put the strongest reason near the end, not on page one. A reasons book reads like a story whether you plan it or not, and the ending is what they will remember.

When should you start, and when is it the right gift?

Give yourself at least a week to write, longer if you are printing. For Christmas, start in late November; for a printed version, order in early December. For Valentine’s Day, start in mid January. A digital version, such as a comic read on screen or a PDF, can be finished the night before if you have to.

A What I Love About You book is the right gift when your partner says they want nothing, when you are better at writing than at shopping, or when the year was hard and deserves acknowledging. It is less right if your partner is uncomfortable with sentiment; in that case, a funnier format such as a comic of your best disaster, or an experience you share, will land better. For more ideas with the same spirit, see our list of the best gifts for couples and our couples page.

So what makes a great What I Love About You book?

Specific moments, their own words, one loved flaw and an ending that matters. The format is secondary: a notebook, a jar, a photo book or a comic all work if the reasons are real. Start a note on your phone tonight, add a reason every time one happens, and by the time you sit down to make the book, most of the writing will already be done.

Frequently asked questions

What do you write in a What I Love About You book?
Specific reasons tied to moments and habits: the first thing you noticed about them, something small they do every morning, a time they surprised you, a way they make hard days easier. Aim for details only the two of you would recognize. A good test is whether the line could be about anyone else; if it could, make it more specific.
How many reasons should a What I Love About You book have?
Fewer than you think. Twenty strong reasons beat a hundred filler ones. Many people pick a number with meaning, such as the years together or the date of the anniversary, but if you run dry, stop. A short honest book reads better than a long padded one.
Is a What I Love About You book a good Christmas gift?
Yes, especially for a partner who says they want nothing. It costs little, it cannot be bought ready made, and it is usually the gift that gets kept in a drawer for years. Start it a couple of weeks before Christmas, because writing good reasons takes several evenings, not one.
Can I make a What I Love About You book as a comic?
Yes. Instead of writing reasons as lines, you turn each one into a short scene with the two of you drawn as characters. On myComics you upload photos of each of you, describe the moments and choose a style, then rewrite every speech bubble in your own words. It is a stylized likeness, closer to a caricature than a portrait, and it suits couples with a few memories they like to retell.
What is the difference between a What I Love About You book and a love story book?
A reasons book is a list: each page is one thing you love about the person. A love story book follows events in order, such as how you met and what happened next. You can combine them: tell the story, and let each scene show one reason. That is often the strongest version of both.