How It WorksProductsExamplesBlog
LoginSign upGo to Dashboard

Comparisons

Best Personalized Comic Book Gifts 2026: Kindred Press, Book by Anyone, Damn Donkey and myComics Compared

Four services, one idea: a comic book where someone you love is the hero. They differ in who writes the story, how much you can change, and how many people fit in it. Here is how to pick.

Last reviewed . Written by our editorial team from our own product knowledge and from what Kindred Press, Book by Anyone and Damn Donkey say publicly on their own websites in November 2026. We have not ordered their books for this piece. We make myComics, one of the four services compared, so weigh our view accordingly.

By the myComics.ai Editorial Team8 min read

Gift guide · Comparison · Editorial disclosure

a woman in her early thirties with curly auburn hair and a green knitted sweater and her husband in his mid thirties with short black hair and a neat beard sitting on a grey sofa next to a decorated Christmas tree, the husband laughing as he holds open a slim printed cartoon style comic book titled The Man Who Burned the Pancakes, its panels showing the two of them drawn as comic characters in a small kitchen full of smoke

Quick answer

  • Kindred Press, Book by Anyone, Damn Donkey and myComics all turn real people into the heroes of a printed comic book, but they split on one question: who writes the story.
  • Kindred Press and Book by Anyone start from editions and templates built for a type of recipient. Damn Donkey writes the comic from a photo and a few answers, then gives you a set number of redraws.
  • myComics is the one where you write the story yourself and can edit every page, panel, character and speech bubble before anything is printed.
  • Pick a template service when you want the fastest possible gift. Pick an editor when the gift depends on one real story being told right.

A personalized comic book has become one of the gifts people actually remember. You have probably seen the ads: a husband drawn as a superhero, a couple’s first date redrawn as a comic, a cat promoted to main character. Behind most of those ads are a handful of services, and in 2026 the names that come up most are Kindred Press, Book by Anyone, Damn Donkey and myComics.

They look alike in an ad. They are not alike once you start making one. This guide compares the four on the things that change the gift: who writes the story, what you can edit, how many people fit, and what you get in your hands. We make myComics, so read our view with that in mind. Everything we say about the other three comes from how they describe their own products.

How do personalized comic books work in 2026?

Every service in this guide uses AI somewhere in the process. The differences are about where you come in.

There are two broad models. In the template model, the service has a story shape ready for a type of recipient: a boyfriend edition, a dad edition, a satirical “bestseller” about your friend. You answer questions, upload photos, and the book is generated around your answers. You get a finished gift quickly, and you trust the template to be funny or sweet in the right places.

In the editor model, you give a premise in your own words and the comic is generated page by page, with you steering. You can rewrite what it gets wrong. It takes a little longer, and the result is closer to your actual story.

Neither model is better for everyone. The right one depends on whether the gift is the laugh or the memory.

What is Kindred Press?

Kindred Press sells a catalog of personalized books, and its custom comic book is the one most people find through social ads. The comic comes in editions for a recipient or an occasion: boyfriend, girlfriend, husband, wife, dad, mom, best friend, anniversary, birthday, Christmas, retirement and many more. Each edition is a page of its own, translated for many countries.

You enter details about the hero, add up to five more characters including pets, and Kindred Press says the book is written and illustrated in about ten minutes, with a free preview shortly after you start. You can review the preview and make changes before it goes to print, and the product page shows an estimated arrival date, which is a nice touch close to the holidays.

What it does well: speed, a clear catalog, and an edition that matches almost any person on your list. If you know the recipient and the occasion, you will find a ready shape for them.

Where it is limited: the story starts from the edition. You shape it through the details you enter rather than writing it scene by scene, so a very specific memory (the night the car broke down, the joke only the two of you get) depends on how well the template absorbs it. If that matters, see our Kindred Press alternative page for a side by side table.

What is a Book by Anyone comic?

Book by Anyone made its name with long, satirical books where your friend or parent appears as the author of a confident book about themselves. It also makes personalized comic books: a classic stapled comic of around twenty pages, made with AI from the details and photos you provide.

The tone is the product. The joke is that your brother has apparently become a legend, and the book is built to be passed around a room and laughed at. You answer questions about the hero, add a photo, and the content is generated for you.

What it does well: a strong, recognizable gag, little effort, and a format that works for big birthdays and office gifts where everyone is in on the joke.

Where it is limited: the content is generated rather than written by you, which is the point and also the limit. If you want an accurate story about a real moment, the satire gets the outline and misses the details. We compare the two formats in more depth in Book by Anyone vs a personalized comic, and the feature table lives on our Book by Anyone alternative page.

over the shoulder view of a husband in his mid thirties with short black hair and a neat beard reading the slim printed cartoon style comic book titled The Man Who Burned the Pancakes on a grey sofa, the open pages filling half the frame and showing him and his wife with curly auburn hair and a green knitted sweater drawn as comic characters, waving a tea towel at a smoking frying pan in a small kitchen

What is Damn Donkey Comics?

Damn Donkey is the newest of the four and the most visible in ads. It builds a full color comic around one hero from a single photo and a few answers, such as their name, their biggest fear and their catchphrase, with friends or pets as the supporting cast. It offers several art styles and longer page counts than most, and sells a collectible 3D figure of the hero alongside the comic.

Its funnel is clever: you see a cover before you pay and can regenerate it as often as you like. After you order, you review the cast and then the pages, with a set number of redraws (two per character, and redraws on up to half of the pages, according to its own site), each review window lasting a day before it is approved automatically.

What it does well: a confident, funny voice, a strong cover hook, a bigger book, and a figure for people who want the full gift box.

Where it is limited: the story is written for you from your answers, and the edits come after you pay and are counted. If you want to keep tweaking dialogue until it sounds exactly like your partner, a fixed number of redraws can feel tight.

What makes myComics different?

myComics is the editor model. You upload a photo of each person, up to six characters in one story, and each one becomes a reusable comic character that keeps the same face from panel to panel. You pick from more than twenty art styles, from cartoon and manga to superhero, 3D and detective noir. Then you describe the story in your own words, and the comic is generated page by page.

The difference is what happens next. Every speech bubble and caption is editable text. You can redraw a single panel, regenerate a character until the face looks right, rewrite a scene, add pages, or change the art style, as often as you want, and nothing is locked until you order the printed book. You also get the comic online and as a PDF, so a late gift can still be given on the day.

What it does well: control. The inside jokes, the real dialogue, the order things happened in. It is also a platform rather than a single product, so the same account makes more comics for the next birthday or anniversary.

Where it is limited: you have to bring the story. If you want someone else to invent the whole thing and you would rather not touch it, a template service will feel easier. The first pages take a few minutes of your attention rather than a few answers in a form.

What does each one let you edit?

Kindred Press Book by Anyone Damn Donkey myComics
Who writes the story Edition template plus your details Generated from your answers Generated from your answers You, with AI drawing and drafting
Edit speech bubbles yourself Changes before print Not stated Through counted redraws Yes, any bubble, any time before print
Redraw panels or characters Not stated Not stated Set number after ordering As often as you like
People in one comic Hero plus up to five Hero plus details One hero plus supporting cast Up to six
Art styles Set by the edition Classic comic Several 20+
Digital copy Not stated Not stated Not stated Online reader and PDF
Preview before paying Free preview Not stated Free cover Free to start, preview before paying

Prices change often, especially near the holidays, so check each product page for the current price and the print cut off before you order. Our own printed book price is on the personalized comic book page.

Which personalized comic book should you choose?

Choose Kindred Press when you know the occasion, want a ready made edition for that person, and value a quick preview and a clear delivery date over writing anything yourself.

Choose Book by Anyone when the gift is the joke. A satirical comic or book about your friend will get the biggest laugh at a party, and you will not have to write a line.

Choose Damn Donkey when you want a bold, funny comic around one hero, a bigger page count, or the comic and a figure together, and you are happy with a few rounds of fixes.

Choose myComics when the gift depends on one real story being told right: how you met, the trip that went wrong, the thing your dad always says. You write it, you fix it, and it sounds like you. Our guide to personalized comic books for adults has premise ideas if you are stuck.

side view of a woman in her early thirties with curly auburn hair and a green knitted sweater leaning on her husband in his mid thirties with short black hair and a neat beard on a grey sofa next to a decorated Christmas tree, both laughing, the closed slim comic book titled The Man Who Burned the Pancakes lying on the coffee table in front of them with its cartoon cover showing the two of them in a smoky kitchen

How do you get a better comic from any of them?

Whichever service you pick, the same few habits make the result better.

  1. Use clear, front facing photos. Good light, no sunglasses, the face fully visible. Every panel is built from them.
  2. Think in moments, not timelines. Three or four specific scenes beat a summary of ten years. “The night we got locked out of the hotel” makes a better page than “we travel a lot”.
  3. Write how they talk. If the service lets you edit dialogue, use their real phrases. That is what makes the recipient laugh on page two.
  4. Leave time for print. Every service here prints to order. Order early in December, and keep a digital version in mind as a backup.
  5. Read it once as the recipient. Before you print, read the whole comic as if you were them. Fix the line that would make them wince.

If you are still choosing between formats, our personalized comic book gift guide covers occasions, and the couples comic page shows how a two person story comes together.

The bottom line

All four services make a comic where someone you love is the hero, and any of them can be a good gift. The real choice is between a template that writes the story for you and an editor where you write it yourself. If you want speed and a ready made joke, the template services are built for that. If you want the story to be yours, down to the last speech bubble, that is what myComics is for.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best personalized comic book gift?
It depends on how much of the story you want to write. If you want a finished gift with almost no effort, a template service such as Kindred Press or Book by Anyone is quick. If you want a specific memory told your way, with real dialogue and inside jokes, a comic you edit yourself on myComics fits better.
Is Kindred Press made with AI?
Kindred Press says its books are written and illustrated in about ten minutes from the details you enter, with a free preview shortly after. That speed points to AI generation working on a template for each edition, such as a boyfriend, dad or anniversary edition.
Can I edit the speech bubbles in a personalized comic book?
On myComics, yes: every speech bubble and caption is editable text, and you can change it as many times as you like before printing. Template services generally let you change names and details in the questions, and Damn Donkey gives a set number of redraws after you order, so check what each one lets you edit before you choose.
How many people can be in a personalized comic book?
Kindred Press allows a main hero plus up to five more characters, including pets. Damn Donkey builds the comic around one hero with friends or pets as the supporting cast. myComics allows up to six characters in one story, each built from their own photos.
Which personalized comic book is fastest for Christmas?
All four print to order, so all four need lead time before Christmas. Check the order cut off each service shows at checkout. If you are late, a digital comic you can share on the day, such as the one myComics gives you as soon as it is made, solves the timing.
Do I need drawing or writing skills?
No. None of the four asks you to draw. Template services also do the writing. On myComics you describe the story in plain words, and the text and art are generated for you to edit, so a few honest sentences about what happened are enough.